Homework: Hindrance or Helpful?
Is ALL homework necessary?
Homework has been a part of almost everyone’s life at
some time or another. I believe that
there are many ways to view the benefits and downfalls of homework. As one who usually had at least two to three
hours of homework each night as a high-school student, a mere part of that led
to retention or learning. Most was
simply memorized for the time being.
Feedback from my instructors was most beneficial to me.
I, as a foreign language instructor, give
little outside homework. I prefer to
watch the students work, correcting and helping them as they work in class. Many of them do not have someone at home who
can help with questions, which may frustrate the kids. They ultimately will have some things to
finish on their own, which allows me to see if they have learned the material
presented to them and to teach them a sense of responsibility.
One major downfall of the homework that I
specifically recall was getting “corrected homework” back, but no feedback from
the teacher to help me figure out what had been done incorrectly. I accepted the grade that I had received and
tried to do better the next time. I
believe that we do learn from our mistakes, not only with homework, but also
with valuable lessons in life. However,
if simple mistakes can be corrected on homework, the teacher should address
them and give feedback in a timely manner in order to help the students learn. Another downfall of homework as I see it is
what some may term as “busy work”. I
would rather engage with my students in class and encourage participation and
learning than give them a “go through the motion” assignment that most will
finish with little to no retention.
Lastly, does homework promote responsibility? In my opinion, the older the students get,
the more they should take responsibility for their actions. As discussed in one of our group sessions,
the instructors who are teaching our upper-level students should expect more
responsible behavior from their students.
They are the teachers who are helping to transition our young adults
into college and the “real world”.
Homework is essential at this level and I believe it helps the student
to learn responsibility. All students
need to see that their future college instructors and ultimately their future
employers will expect them to be responsible in order to be successful young
adults.
In conclusion, I feel that homework has its benefits as
well as its downfalls. I also believe
that instructors should take into consideration the busy lives that some of
their students may have, and, in turn, limit the load of homework given. Ultimately, is it “busy work” or are the
students actually learning from the homework that is given?
Feedback is so powerful for students. Feedback and homework should go together. If we are going to assign homework then students deserve high quality feedback. I am anxious to have the feedback discussion when we get to grading.
ReplyDeleteNice work!
I keep reading a lot of teachers talk about homework "preparing our students for college." What about our students that aren't planning on going to college, but will probably be very successful doing something like taking over the family farm? How do we justify homework for them?
ReplyDelete